Early Access — All reports and features are 100% free while we collect feedback. Send us feedback
FB
FranchiseBreakdown
Compare All Brands Learn Home
Filing: 2025 · Data imported 2026-02-11 Data Source: Official FDD Filing (2025)

Brightway Insurance: key questions

How much does a Brightway Insurance franchise cost?

Brightway Insurance's displayed initial investment range is $23,325 to $136,900, from the 2025 FDD. Check the Item 7 table for the applicable business format, location assumptions and exclusions.

Which filing does this report use?

This report uses the 2025 FDD. Filing year is not the year of every financial figure: revenue and outlet tables can describe earlier periods. Figures are extracted automatically and may contain errors.

Are reported revenue and closure rates a forecast of my results?

No. Item 19 figures describe disclosed cohorts and periods, not guaranteed income or profit. Outlet closures in Item 20 do not measure every form of business failure. Estimated profit and the Franchise Breakdown score are calculations, not audited FDD facts or customer reviews.

Data sources, verification and methodology

See full cost breakdown →

Brightway Insurance Franchise: Cost, Earnings & Real FDD Data

Insurance

Brightway Insurance is an insurance agency franchise that offers comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage. The franchise combines digital technology with personalized agent service to help clients find appropriate coverage at competitive rates.

Jacksonville, Florida · Founded 2003 · Franchising since 2008 · brightway.com →

68.0
Good
341
Total Units
N/A
Median Revenue
$23K – $137K
Total Investment
N/A
Royalty Rate
N/A
Est. Profit
4.7%
Closure Rate

The Brightway Insurance franchise requires a total investment of $23K – $137K and operates 341 units in the Insurance category. This report analyzes the full Franchise Disclosure Document including unit economics, fee structure, growth trends, and risk indicators to help you evaluate the cost of investing in Brightway Insurance.

★ Key Takeaways

Growth Signal
Net +51 units over 3 years (+17.8% growth)
Fee Burden
Royalty + ad fund = 3.0% of gross sales, vs 22.0% category average
Financial Disclosure
This brand discloses financial performance data (Item 19)

Deal Breakers 1 flag detected

Critical issues identified from FDD analysis that warrant serious consideration before investing.

Closures Accelerating (+6 more closures vs prior year)
Franchise closures increased from 10 to 16 over the reporting period. An upward trend in closures is a warning sign.
Question to ask the franchisor:
What is causing the increase in closures? Are these concentrated in certain regions or demographics?

Franchise Breakdown Score 68.0/100 · Good

Composite quality score based on growth, stability, efficiency, fees, transparency, and system size.

Unit Growth
15/20
Stability
8/20
Investment Efficiency
10/20
Fee Reasonableness
15/15
Transparency
10/10
System Size
10/15

1 How Much Does a Brightway Insurance Franchise Cost? FDD Item 7

Estimated initial investment range as disclosed in the most recent FDD.

Total Estimated Investment
$23K -- $137K
Midpoint
$80K
View detailed breakdown table
Line Item Low Estimate High Estimate
Franchise Fee $10,000 $25,000
Real Estate $0 $7,000
Buildout $0 $10,000
Equipment $0 $7,000
Equipment $2,300 $6,700
Signage $125 $15,000
Legal Accounting $600 $2,500
Insurance $300 $4,000
Other $0 $1,200
Other $0 $3,500
Working Capital $10,000 $55,000
Total $23,325 $136,900

2 Fee Structure FDD Items 5 & 6

Ongoing fees as disclosed in the FDD.

Ad Fund
0% Avg 2.0% 8%
3.0%
Franchise Fee
$0 Avg $43K $75K
$25K

Core Recurring Fees

Sales Commissions – New Business (Brightway Sales Commissions on New Business)
20.0% monthly
Sales Commissions – Renewal Business (Brightway Sales Commissions on Renewal Business)
50.0% monthly
Other Advertising and Marketing Programs; Cooperative Advertising (Brightway Sales Commissions)
3.0% monthly

Technology Fees

Franchisee Shared Expenses – Per-Brightway Location Technology Fee $200 /monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Per-Active User Technology Fee $209 /monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Per-Inactive User Technology Fee $75 /monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Brightway Fusion $90 /monthly
Est. Monthly Total (fixed) ~$574/mo

Other Recurring Fees

Agency Owner Shared Expenses – Miscellaneous Fees (Various expenses including carrier appointment fees, MVR charges, customer mailing costs, E&O premiums)
Variable
Bad/No Email Address Fee (Per customer per year)
$5 monthly
Post-Term Extended Earnings (Variable amount paid to franchisee over 24 months)
Variable

One-Time & Situational Fees

Transfer Fee – Majority Interest Variable
Transfer Fee – Minority Interest $2,500
Insurance 18.0%
+ 6 more situational fees
Costs and Attorneys' Fees Associated with Enforcement or Collection Variable
Supplier/Product Evaluation Variable
Financial Records and Reports Variable
Taxes Variable
FCI Commission Variable
Indemnification Variable
View complete fee table (19 items)
Fee Type Rate Type Basis Frequency
Sales Commissions – New Business 20.0% PCT Brightway Sales Commissions on New Business monthly
Sales Commissions – Renewal Business 50.0% PCT Brightway Sales Commissions on Renewal Business monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Per-Brightway Location Technology Fee $200 FIXED Per Location Monthly monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Per-Active User Technology Fee $209 FIXED Per Active User Monthly monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Per-Inactive User Technology Fee $75 FIXED Per Inactive User Monthly monthly
Franchisee Shared Expenses – Brightway Fusion $90 FIXED Per User Monthly monthly
Agency Owner Shared Expenses – Miscellaneous Fees N/A VARIABLE Various expenses including carrier appointment fees, MVR charges, customer mailing costs, E&O premiums monthly
Transfer Fee – Majority Interest N/A VARIABLE Initial Fee in effect as of transfer date one_time
Transfer Fee – Minority Interest $2,500 FIXED Per transfer one_time
Other Advertising and Marketing Programs; Cooperative Advertising 3.0% PCT Brightway Sales Commissions monthly
Costs and Attorneys' Fees Associated with Enforcement or Collection N/A VARIABLE Franchisor's actual costs and expenses one_time
Insurance 18.0% PCT Premium cost plus 18% administrative costs one_time
Supplier/Product Evaluation N/A VARIABLE Brightway's actual testing costs one_time
Financial Records and Reports N/A VARIABLE Cost of preparing required financial reports one_time
Taxes N/A VARIABLE Amount of tax assessed one_time
Bad/No Email Address Fee $5 FIXED Per customer per year monthly
FCI Commission N/A VARIABLE Portion of commissions from non-admitted carriers one_time
Post-Term Extended Earnings N/A VARIABLE Variable amount paid to franchisee over 24 months monthly
Indemnification N/A VARIABLE Losses and expenses incurred by franchisor and affiliates one_time

3 Brightway Insurance Franchise Revenue & Earnings (Item 19) Item 19 Available FDD Item 19

Financial performance data as disclosed in FDD Item 19.

$244K
Average Revenue
$169K
Median Revenue
View all disclosed financial metrics (122 rows)
Annualized Premium for Calendar Year Ending December 31, 2024 (7 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Average Tenure (years) 16.0 OTHER Over $50M 2024
Average Tenure (years) 12.0 OTHER Between $25M & $50M 2024
Average Tenure (years) 12.0 OTHER Between $15M & $25M 2024
Average Tenure (years) 13.0 OTHER Between $10M & $15M 2024
Average Tenure (years) 11.0 OTHER Between $5M & $10M 2024
Average Tenure (years) 7.0 OTHER Between $1M & $5M 2024
Average Tenure (years) 2.0 OTHER Under $1M 2024
AVERAGE PRODUCTION BASED ON NUMBER OF PRODUCERS IN AGENCY (August 2024 – July 2025) (15 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Number of Brightway Locations 118.0 COUNT 1 August 2024 – July 2025
Average New Business Production 156.0 COUNT 1 August 2024 – July 2025
Median New Business Production 103.0 COUNT 1 August 2024 – July 2025
Number of Brightway Locations 57.0 COUNT 2 August 2024 – July 2025
Average New Business Production 285.0 COUNT 2 August 2024 – July 2025
Median New Business Production 194.0 COUNT 2 August 2024 – July 2025
Number of Brightway Locations 41.0 COUNT 3 August 2024 – July 2025
Average New Business Production 540.0 COUNT 3 August 2024 – July 2025
Median New Business Production 467.0 COUNT 3 August 2024 – July 2025
Number of Brightway Locations 32.0 COUNT 4 August 2024 – July 2025
Average New Business Production 875.0 COUNT 4 August 2024 – July 2025
Median New Business Production 677.0 COUNT 4 August 2024 – July 2025
Number of Brightway Locations 32.0 COUNT 5+ August 2024 – July 2025
Average New Business Production 1860.0 COUNT 5+ August 2024 – July 2025
Median New Business Production 1730.0 COUNT 5+ August 2024 – July 2025
Gross Commission Revenue by Number of Producers (18 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Top 25% Average Revenue $266,014 USD 1 Producer 2024
Average Revenue $93,737 USD 1 Producer 2024
Bottom 25% Average Revenue $10,967 USD 1 Producer 2024
Median Revenue $45,908 USD 1 Producer 2024
High $1,221,537 USD 1 Producer 2024
Low $545 USD 1 Producer 2024
Top 25% Average Revenue $605,220 USD 2 Producers 2024
Average Revenue $244,388 USD 2 Producers 2024
Bottom 25% Average Revenue $19,084 USD 2 Producers 2024
Median Revenue $169,309 USD 2 Producers 2024
High $1,390,823 USD 2 Producers 2024
Low $5,749 USD 2 Producers 2024
Top 25% Average Revenue $2,082,043 USD Fully-staffed (3+ Producers) 2024
Average Revenue $906,320 USD Fully-staffed (3+ Producers) 2024
Bottom 25% Average Revenue $196,604 USD Fully-staffed (3+ Producers) 2024
Median Revenue $655,298 USD Fully-staffed (3+ Producers) 2024
High $4,909,765 USD Fully-staffed (3+ Producers) 2024
Low $20,374 USD Fully-staffed (3+ Producers) 2024
Million Dollar Producers (3 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Number of Full-Time Producers with $1m+ in Annualized Premium 62.0 COUNT -- 2024
Number of Full-Time Producers with $500,000 to $1m in Annualized Premium 120.0 COUNT -- 2024
Number of Full-Time Producers with less than $500,000 in Annualized Premium 299.0 COUNT -- 2024
NEW BUSINESS POLICY PRODUCTION BY FULL-TIME PRODUCERS (2024) (18 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Top 25% 483.0 COUNT New Business Policies Sold per Producer in 2024 2024
Average 221.0 COUNT New Business Policies Sold per Producer in 2024 2024
Bottom 25% 68.0 COUNT New Business Policies Sold per Producer in 2024 2024
Median 158.0 COUNT New Business Policies Sold per Producer in 2024 2024
High 3015.0 COUNT New Business Policies Sold per Producer in 2024 2024
Low 50.0 COUNT New Business Policies Sold per Producer in 2024 2024
Top 25% $1,178,177 USD New Business Annualized Premium per Producer 2024
Average $537,603 USD New Business Annualized Premium per Producer 2024
Bottom 25% $156,185 USD New Business Annualized Premium per Producer 2024
Median $393,934 USD New Business Annualized Premium per Producer 2024
High $4,271,505 USD New Business Annualized Premium per Producer 2024
Low $60,559 USD New Business Annualized Premium per Producer 2024
Number of Producers 120.0 COUNT Top 25% 2024
Number of Producers 481.0 COUNT Average 2024
Number of Producers 120.0 COUNT Bottom 25% 2024
Number of Producers 1.0 COUNT Median 2024
Number of Producers 1.0 COUNT High 2024
Number of Producers 1.0 COUNT Low 2024
SUMMARY OF ANNUALIZED PREMIUM BY AGENCY OWNER (2024) (21 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Number of Agency Owners 1.0 COUNT Over $50M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 0.0 COUNT Over $50M 2024
Number of Locations 1.0 COUNT Over $50M 2024
Number of Agency Owners 8.0 COUNT Between $25M & $50M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 4.0 COUNT Between $25M & $50M 2024
Number of Locations 13.0 COUNT Between $25M & $50M 2024
Number of Agency Owners 15.0 COUNT Between $15M & $25M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 4.0 COUNT Between $15M & $25M 2024
Number of Locations 19.0 COUNT Between $15M & $25M 2024
Number of Agency Owners 16.0 COUNT Between $10M & $15M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 3.0 COUNT Between $10M & $15M 2024
Number of Locations 19.0 COUNT Between $10M & $15M 2024
Number of Agency Owners 32.0 COUNT Between $5M & $10M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 1.0 COUNT Between $5M & $10M 2024
Number of Locations 33.0 COUNT Between $5M & $10M 2024
Number of Agency Owners 76.0 COUNT Between $1M & $5M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 3.0 COUNT Between $1M & $5M 2024
Number of Locations 79.0 COUNT Between $1M & $5M 2024
Number of Agency Owners 106.0 COUNT Under $1M 2024
Number of Multi-Unit Location Owners 0.0 COUNT Under $1M 2024
Number of Locations 106.0 COUNT Under $1M 2024
Table 5-A (20 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Low PIF 60.0 COUNT Year 1 FY2020
Median PIF 218.0 COUNT Year 1 FY2020
Average PIF 268.0 COUNT Year 1 FY2020
High PIF 660.0 COUNT Year 1 FY2020
Low PIF 159.0 COUNT Year 2 FY2021
Median PIF 500.0 COUNT Year 2 FY2021
Average PIF 597.0 COUNT Year 2 FY2021
High PIF 1438.0 COUNT Year 2 FY2021
Low PIF 137.0 COUNT Year 3 FY2022
Median PIF 813.0 COUNT Year 3 FY2022
Average PIF 917.0 COUNT Year 3 FY2022
High PIF 2250.0 COUNT Year 3 FY2022
Low PIF 87.0 COUNT Year 4 FY2023
Median PIF 1072.0 COUNT Year 4 FY2023
Average PIF 1179.0 COUNT Year 4 FY2023
High PIF 3611.0 COUNT Year 4 FY2023
Low PIF 76.0 COUNT Year 5 FY2024
Median PIF 1113.0 COUNT Year 5 FY2024
Average PIF 1373.0 COUNT Year 5 FY2024
High PIF 4940.0 COUNT Year 5 FY2024
Table 5-B (20 rows)
Metric Value Unit Cohort Period
Low Gross Commission Revenue $0 USD Year 1 FY2020
Median Gross Commission Revenue $30,000 USD Year 1 FY2020
Average Gross Commission Revenue $44,000 USD Year 1 FY2020
High Gross Commission Revenue $133,000 USD Year 1 FY2020
Low Gross Commission Revenue $32,000 USD Year 2 FY2021
Median Gross Commission Revenue $52,000 USD Year 2 FY2021
Average Gross Commission Revenue $102,000 USD Year 2 FY2021
High Gross Commission Revenue $300,000 USD Year 2 FY2021
Low Gross Commission Revenue $29,000 USD Year 3 FY2022
Median Gross Commission Revenue $142,000 USD Year 3 FY2022
Average Gross Commission Revenue $162,000 USD Year 3 FY2022
High Gross Commission Revenue $441,000 USD Year 3 FY2022
Low Gross Commission Revenue $20,000 USD Year 4 FY2023
Median Gross Commission Revenue $204,000 USD Year 4 FY2023
Average Gross Commission Revenue $221,000 USD Year 4 FY2023
High Gross Commission Revenue $616,000 USD Year 4 FY2023
Low Gross Commission Revenue $19,000 USD Year 5 FY2024
Median Gross Commission Revenue $245,000 USD Year 5 FY2024
Average Gross Commission Revenue $268,000 USD Year 5 FY2024
High Gross Commission Revenue $800,000 USD Year 5 FY2024

Investment Calculator Interactive

Model your personal financial scenario by adjusting the assumptions below.

Annual Revenue
Operating Margin
Initial Investment
Loan Percentage
Gross Revenue
Royalty + Ad Fund
Operating Profit
Annual Loan Payment
Net Annual Cash Flow
Payback Period
5-Year Total Return
Break-Even Monthly Rev
This calculator is for illustrative purposes only. Actual results will vary based on location, management, market conditions, and other factors. Always consult with a financial advisor and franchise attorney before making investment decisions.

4 Risk Assessment

Automated risk indicators based on FDD data analysis.

~
Moderate Closure Rate
Average closure rate of 4.7% is in the 2-5% range. Monitor trends closely.
↑
Growing System
Net +51 units over 3 years (+17.8%). Healthy franchise expansion.
%
Reasonable Fee Burden
Combined royalty + ad fund of 3.0% is within normal range.
✓
Financial Data Disclosed
This franchisor provides Item 19 financial performance representations, enabling better due diligence.

5 Brightway Insurance Failure Rate & Unit Growth (Item 20) FDD Item 20

Franchise unit trajectory based on FDD Item 20 data.

Year Start Opened Closed Transferred End Closure Rate Net Growth
2022 287 +63 -10 4 285 3.5% --
2023 285 +108 -17 0 335 6.0% --
2024 335 +67 -16 0 338 4.8% --
4.7%
Avg Closure Rate
3
Years of Data

6 Category Comparison Insurance Brands

How Brightway Insurance compares to peer brands in the Insurance category.

Investment Midpoint

Median Revenue (Item 19)

Investment-to-Revenue Ratio

Ratio = Investment midpoint ÷ median annual revenue. Lower is better. A 0.5x ratio means the initial investment equals half of one year's gross revenue. Does not account for operating costs, margins, or time value of money.

Brand Total Units Investment Range Median Revenue Royalty Inv/Rev Ratio
Goosehead Insurance Agency 1115 $66K – $108K $86K 20.0% 1.0x
Brightway Insurance 341 $23K – $137K $94K 20.0% 0.9x

■ SBA Loan Data 2015–2017

SBA 7(a) loan approvals for Brightway Insurance franchisees from the SBA FOIA public dataset. Lenders report franchise codes at origination — this is real lending activity, not estimates.

$2M
Total SBA Approved
11
SBA Loans
$138K
Avg Loan Size
18.2%
Default Rate
Active Lending States 6
Distinct Lenders 4
Jobs Supported 57
Top Lending States
FL 4 PA 2 NC 2 TX 1 OK 1
Annual SBA Loan Volume

Source: SBA FOIA 7(a) public data. Franchise codes matched by brand name. Not all SBA loans are captured; some franchisees finance without SBA programs.

Similar Brands to Explore

Other franchise brands with similar characteristics you may want to consider.

Compare these brands

Compare Brightway Insurance

See how Brightway Insurance stacks up against similar franchise brands side by side.

Researching a franchise investment?

Leave your details and we'll notify you when we add new data for Brightway Insurance — including updated FDD extractions, revenue comparisons, and market analysis.

You're on the list.

We'll be in touch when new data is available.